When you think of engagement rings, diamonds might be the first thing that comes to mind. But what if you’re looking for something unique, colorful, or even more budget-friendly? Non-diamond engagement rings are rising in popularity, offering stunning alternatives that are just as meaningful and durable.
If you’re considering a popular engagement ring gemstone that isn’t a diamond, this guide will help you explore the best gemstones for engagement rings—from classic sapphires to trendy morganite and beyond.
Why Choose a Non-Diamond Engagement Ring?
Choosing a diamond alternative for engagement rings comes with several benefits:
✅ Unique & Personalized – Stand out with a rare or colorful gem.
✅ More Affordable – Some gems offer incredible beauty at a lower price than diamonds.
✅ Ethical & Sustainable – Many non-diamond options are more eco-friendly and conflict-free.
✅ Timeless Elegance – Many gemstones hold symbolic meaning and rich history.
Top Gemstone Choices for Engagement Rings1. Sapphire Engagement Rings – The Royal Favorite 👑
- Why it’s great: Sapphires are one of the hardest gemstones (9 on the Mohs scale), making them an excellent choice for daily wear engagement rings.
- Best colors: While deep blue is the most well-known, sapphires come in pink, yellow, and even white (which can resemble a diamond!).
- Famous example: Princess Diana’s sapphire engagement ring, now worn by Kate Middleton.
2. Emerald Engagement Rings – A Symbol of Love & Growth 💚
- Why it’s great: Emeralds are luxurious and represent eternal love and renewal.
- Durability tip: Emeralds (7.5–8 on the Mohs scale) require more care than sapphires or diamonds, but they’re still a stunning choice.
- Perfect for: Vintage or antique-inspired engagement rings.
3. Moissanite vs. Diamond: The Best Alternative 💎
- Why it’s great: Moissanite sparkles even more than a diamond and is nearly as hard (9.25 on the Mohs scale).
- Affordability: A moissanite engagement ring costs a fraction of a diamond’s price.
- Sustainability: Moissanite is lab-created, making it an ethical gemstone engagement ring option.
4. Morganite Engagement Rings – The Trendy Blush Pink Stone 🌸
- Why it’s great: Morganite’s soft pink hue symbolizes love, romance, and femininity.
- Best setting: Pairs beautifully with rose gold for a warm, vintage-inspired look.
- Perfect for: Those who love a colorful engagement ring with a soft, dreamy aesthetic.
5. Ruby Engagement Rings – Bold & Passionate ❤️
- Why it’s great: Rubies are nearly as hard as sapphires (9 on the Mohs scale), making them one of the best durable engagement ring gemstones.
- Symbolism: Represents passion, protection, and good fortune.
- Best for: Those who want a bold, vibrant gemstone engagement ring.
Pros and Cons of Gemstone Engagement RingsGemstoneHardness (Mohs Scale)ProsConsSapphire9Extremely durable, many colors availableCan be expensiveEmerald7.5–8Timeless, luxuriousRequires more careMoissanite9.25More brilliance than diamonds, affordableNot as rare as natural stonesMorganite7.5–8Romantic pink hue, budget-friendlySofter, needs extra careRuby9Strong, classic, represents loveHigh-quality rubies can be priceyHow to Choose the Best Gemstone for Your Engagement Ring
When selecting a non-diamond engagement ring, consider these factors:
💍 Durability – If you wear your ring daily, opt for hard gemstones like sapphire, ruby, or moissanite.
💍 Budget – Morganite and moissanite are excellent, affordable options.
💍 Color Preference – Love classic blue? Sapphire. Prefer soft pink? Morganite. Want bold red? Ruby.
💍 Ethical Concerns – Choose lab-grown gemstones or sustainably sourced gems.
Where to Buy Unique Gemstone Engagement Rings
Looking for a custom engagement ring with gemstones? At CMJ & Diamonds, we specialize in crafting one-of-a-kind engagement rings using ethically sourced gemstones and high-quality materials. Whether you want a sapphire engagement ring, a moissanite alternative, or a colorful gemstone engagement ring, we can bring your dream design to life.
🔹 Explore our custom jewelry collection today!
Final Thoughts
While diamonds remain a classic choice, alternative engagement rings with colorful gemstones offer personality, uniqueness, and affordability. Whether you love the elegance of sapphires, the romance of morganite, or the brilliance of moissanite, there’s a perfect gemstone for everyone.
What’s your favorite non-diamond engagement ring gemstone? Let us know in the comments!